| LP 1 | |
| Side A: | |
| 1. Hello Mary Lou (Goodbye Heart) - Ricky Nelson | |
| 2. Lazarus - Michael C. Hall & Original New York Cast Of Lazarus | |
| 3. It's No Game - Michael C. Hall, Lynn Craig & Original New York Cast Of Lazarus | |
| 4. This Is Not America - Sophia Anne Caruso & Original New York Cast Of Lazarus | |
| 5. The Man Who Sold The World - Charlie Pollock | |
| - | |
| Side B: | |
| 1. No Plan - Sophia Anne Caruso | |
| 2. Love Is Lost - Michael Esper & Original New York Cast Of Lazarus | |
| 3. Changes - Cristin Milioti & Original New York Cast Of Lazarus | |
| 4. Where Are We Now? - Michael C. Hall & Original New York Cast Of Lazarus | |
| . | |
| LP 2 | |
| Side C: | |
| 1. Absolute Beginners - Michael C. Hall, Cristin Milioti, Michael Esper, Sophia Anne Caruso, Krystina Alabado & Original New York Cast Of Lazarus | |
| 2. Dirty Boys - Michael Esper | |
| 3. Killing A Little Time - Michael C. Hall | |
| 4. Life On Mars? - Sophia Anne Caruso | |
| 5. All The Young Dudes - Nicholas Christopher, Lynn Craig, Michael Esper, Sophia Anne Caruso & Original New York Cast Of Lazarus | |
| - | |
| Side D: | |
| 1. Sound And Vision - David Bowie | |
| 2. Always Crashing In The Same Car - Cristin Milioti | |
| 3. Valentine's Day - Michael Esper & Original New York Cast Of Lazarus | |
| 4. When I Met You - Michael C. Hall & Krystina Alabado | |
| 5. "Heroes" - Michael C. Hall, Sophia Anne Caruso & Original New York Cast Of Lazarus | |
| . | |
| LP 3 | |
| Side E: | |
| 1. Lazarus - David Bowie | |
| 2. No Plan - David Bowie | |
| 3. Killing A Little Time - David Bowie | |
| 4. When I Met You - David Bowie | |
| - | |
| Side F: | |
| [blank] | |
